Just months ago, Israel was a world leader in vaccinating its population and appeared to be putting a stranglehold on the virus that causes COVID-19, wrestling down its daily case count to double digits — and at times, near zero.
But any potential celebration was short-lived, as the more contagious delta variant gained traction and spread quickly, to the point where Israel’s most recent daily case count was around 11,000 — a level not seen since January.
According to some Israeli scientists, this reversal of fortune provides lessons for countries like Canada, as we enter a fourth wave, to remain cautious about letting any guard down — to avoid some of the mistakes their country made.
“This is a very clear warning sign for the rest of the world,” said Dr. Ran Balicer, chief innovation officer at Clalit Health Services (CHS), in a recent interview with the magazine Science.
“If it can happen here, it can probably happen everywhere.”
While Israel often topped the list by Oxford University-based Our World in Data of population vaccinated, now it’s leading in another category: It has the world’s highest seven-day rolling average of new daily coronavirus cases per million people.
On Tuesday, Israel’s Ministry of Health reported that the country had set a new daily record for diagnosed coronavirus cases at nearly 11,000, which comes as the delta variant surges across much of the world.
There were 716 people in the country hospitalized and in serious condition with COVID-19 complications, including 159 on ventilators, the Times of Israel reported.
And while Israel went several weeks in May without a death, more than 550 people have died of COVID-19 in August, including over 100 of them in the last five days, the Times reported.
“It seems that some mistakes were made when we thought we won the war, and now we understand we only won the battle. The war is still here, and we have to continue and to explain and push all the people to get vaccinated,” Israel’s coronavirus czar, Prof. Salman Zarka, said in a recent interview with the Times.
Meanwhile, Israeli health officials reported what appeared to be a waning efficacy of the vaccine, including among those who had been double vaccinated. Data showed that of the serious cases being admitted to hospital, around 60 per cent of patients were people who had been fully vaccinated, though most were over 60 or with underlying health conditions.
Herd immunity believed reached
“Many public health professionals feel that what happened in Israel was a demonstration of population immunity, or herd immunity. [But the] delta variant, with its higher infectious rate, coupled with waning immunity, has proven us wrong,” said Dr. Eyal Leshem, a clinical associate professor in internal medicine and infectious diseases at the Sackler School of Medicine in Tel Aviv University, in an interview with CBC News.
In May, with herd immunity believed to have been established and cases dwindling down to double digits, with few deaths, Israel began easing up on its public health restrictions. Businesses and schools were returning to normal.
Then, at the beginning of June, capacity limits at stores and restaurants were lifted, as well as for indoor and outdoor gatherings. Israelis also no longer needed proof of vaccination to enter various venues.
By mid-June, indoor mask requirements were lifted.
“The government … decided we shouldn’t impose restrictions; we will rely on vaccines for protection. But then we realized that it is very difficult to stop the infections with the delta variant,” said Cyrille Cohen, head of the lab of immunotherapy at Bar-Ilan University and a member of the Israeli Health Ministry’s advisory committee for clinical trials on COVID-19 vaccines.
“What we should have done is to keep some restrictions — for example, wearing of the mask inside,” he said.
As the country’s cases rapidly increased again, the government reversed course. Mandatory masks and its green pass regime were again required to enter indoor public spaces.
Between January and March, Israel had been very proactive and innovative, explained Nadav Davidovitch, director of the School of Public Health at Ben Gurion University of the Negev. “And then we became much more passive.”
Significant number still unvaccinated
Israel has so far fully vaccinated around 62 per cent of its population. But that still leaves a significant number of people unvaccinated, said Dr. Isaac Bogoch, an infectious diseases physician and member of Ontario’s COVID-19 vaccine task force.
“You’ve got a million unvaccinated folks, plus a very contagious delta variant, plus opportunities for the virus to be transmitted,” he said. “So you can’t get surprised that there’s a big rise in cases.”
The most cautionary tale for Canada could be observations that the rate of infection has been found to be higher in people vaccinated back in January, compared with people who were vaccinated in April, said Leshem.
“In simple words: That protection against infection is waning over time.”
These results were observed in people who were double vaccinated, regardless of age or whether they were immunocompromised, he said.
Leshem said this development, along with the fear that a rise in severe infections would overwhelm the health-care system, prompted Israel to become the first country to launch a booster shot campaign, with a third dose going to those aged 60 and over. Boosters are now available to everyone aged 30 or older.
So far, the results of the booster campaign suggest the third dose is probably effective both in preventing infection and in reducing the number of severe breakthrough infections and hospitalization, Leshem said.
“So what we’re seeing on the ground in COVID wards — in my hospital and other hospitals — is that while the number of cases continue to increase, we’ve seen a stabilization in the number of severe cases,” he said. “The most plausible reason is that this older population that was boosted is more protected against severe infection, hospitalization and death.”
The disease is still expanding, Leshem said, and Israel is still seeing more and more cases every day — “but at a slower rate.”
According to Cohen, the lesson countries like Canada can learn from Israel’s experience is that a focus must be maintained on the populations at highest risk.
“As the number of infections rises, you really want to make sure this population is protected in an optimal way,” he said.
In terms of policy, governments need to maintain some level of restriction, like limiting gatherings, said Cohen.
“I was a proponent of having … tighter restrictions like a month-and-a-half ago. That was actually my personal advice when I was asked by officials here so that we would not end up in this situation,” Cohen said. “They decided against that.”
To Canadians and Canadian lawmakers, his advice is to open up gradually — and the moment there is a steady rise in cases, don’t wait to act. “Because the higher the rise, the more difficult it is to stop with simple measures.”
He also advises that people keep masking while indoors and to use rapid testing for vulnerable people attending family gatherings.
And his message to Canadians who were vaccinated more than six months ago: “You are vulnerable. You are more vulnerable than what you were three months ago, especially when facing the delta variant.”